Head of Commodity Strategy
Summary: A look back on developments that shaped the commodities market in 2023, a year that began on an optimistic note with focus on China’s reopening after months of Covid-related lockdowns sending the market off to a good start. But it wasn’t all bliss as markets grew increasingly worried about the risk of an economic fallout from continued and aggressive central bank rate hikes aimed at bringing inflation under control. Aside from economic growth and demand concerns weighing on energy and industrial metals, diverging weather developments played an important role, leading to some of the best, but also worst performances.
As the 2023 hourglass runs out, it’s time to reflect on what kind of year it has been for commodities: a pretty mixed bag filled with good, bad and surprises. Aside from economic growth and demand concerns weighing on energy and industrial metals, diverging weather developments played an important role, leading to some of the best, but also worst performances.
The year began on an optimistic note with focus on China’s reopening after months of Covid-related lockdowns sending the market off to a good start. But it wasn’t all bliss as markets grew increasingly worried about the risk of an economic fallout from continued and aggressive central bank rate hikes aimed at bringing inflation under control. These concerns only began to ease this quarter when markets finally received a nod that the next move in rates would likely be lower. A war in the Middle East, Russia’s continued aggressions in Ukraine, and attacks on ships in Red Sea all added up to a year that saw increased geopolitical risks and with that an increasingly fragmented world.
It was also a year that saw the green transformation gather momentum, especially in China where fuel demand looks set to peak next year. However, that focus did little to support capital intensive companies involved with the transition as they faced heavy selling pressure during the second half of the year amid lofty valuations coming under pressure from a rapid rise in the cost of money as interest rates and yields surged higher. Saxo’s equity themes highlight this weakness with green transformation, renewable energy and energy storage being the worst performing themes while the commodities theme is found near mid-table after returning around 12%.
However, with funding costs coming down next year and with ongoing efforts to combat climate change, we suspect these under-owned sectors could see a comeback in 2024. With global demand for energy still rising, this transition process however is for now more of a green addition, after demand for gas, crude and coal also reached fresh record highs.
In the previous two years, the Bloomberg Commodity Total Return Index – which tracks the performance of 24 major commodity futures, spread almost evenly between energy, metals and agriculture – has returned 27% in 2021 and 16% in 2022. With that in mind, it was probably not unreasonable, given the challenges this past year, to see the index give back around 8%. Do note that if we exclude US natural gas, which slumped 67%, from the index it would trade near unchanged on the year.
Supporting returns was another year where several key commodities traded in backwardation, a situation that reflects tight market conditions, and it helped create a positive roll yield when expiring futures contracts were rolled into a lower priced next month contract. While the year-on-year roll yield has moderated to 3.3% from around 9.4% this time last year, it is still providing some tailwind for investors that was absent in the pre-Covid years when the roll yield was averaging around -5%.
At the beginning of the year the tightness was primarily seen across the energy sector – where crude oil and refined products, such as gasoline and especially diesel were very tight amid Russian sanctions and China demand optimism. However, from May onwards, the agriculture sector took over as El Niño weather developments, primarily across the Southern Hemisphere, helped trigger tight market conditions and surging prices of sugar, cocoa and coffee – this year’s top three performers - thereby more than offsetting the negative pull from weaker grain prices following a robust Northern Hemisphere harvest season.
As per the table below, we can see the role that some key commodities have played in helping bring inflation under control. The UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) food price index showed a 10.7% year-on-year drop in November, led by declines in grains such as wheat and corn, as well as vegetable oils and dairy. Natural gas, a key source of energy used in power generation, suffered major declines across the world, most notably in the US where record production and high inventories and mild weather helped drive a 67% slump, but also in Europe where gas prices continued lower following their 2022 surge amid strong production from renewable sources, mild weather, an improved ability to receive Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) to replace pipelined gas from Russia, and not least weaker industrial demand.
Gold, up around 12% on the year after trading within a wide 330 dollar range, delivered a somewhat surprisingly robust performance, driven by continued central bank demand and retail buyers in Asia, in the process more than offsetting continued selling from investors focusing on sharply higher real yields and the rising funding cost of holding a position amid the continued rise in US short-term interest rates. It is, however, worth noting that the bulk of the gain was realized during Q4 when central banks finally indicated the next move in rates would likely be lower.
A 12% slump in the Bloomberg Industrial Metal index was primarily driven by weakness in nickel, zinc and aluminum, and only partly offset by gains in tin and not least copper which gained 5% amid surprisingly strong demand in China, not least from the green transition given its usage in multiple applications. As the year comes to a close, the copper market has found support from multiple short- and long-term supply disruptions, and together with already low inventory levels, potential restocking from industrial users as funding costs come down, we are likely to see continued support in 2024.
Brent spent the year trading in a relatively small 27.5 dollar range compared with the 64 dollar range seen in 2022 when the war in Ukraine drove the market sharply higher, before collapsing. At the current price of around $80, it trades just a couple of bucks below the average for the year, and this relatively small range can be credited to OPEC+ and its attempt to maintain stable prices through actively managing supply. There is no doubt, however, that the group would like to see prices higher but rising production from the US and Iran among others, together with Q4 demand weakness, has left the group with only with a half victory given the failure to boost prices while surrendering market share.
Continued selling since October by hedge funds and commodity trading advisors (CTA) has resulted in the net long position across 24 major commodity futures collapsing to levels last seen at the depths of the Covid crisis in early 2020 when global demand for commodities, especially fuel, fell off a cliff.
These developments highlight an increasingly under-owned asset class which has struggled in 2023 amid growth worries in China and the wider world, and a sharp rise in funding costs leading industries to reduce excess inventories. It also highlights a sector which, given the right circumstances, may see a strong recovery in 2024 once the technical and/or fundamental outlook becomes more supportive, thereby leading to fresh buying and short covering. Drivers that may trigger such a change could be rate cuts lowering the funding costs and with that the inherent contango leading to industry restocking of inventories, OPEC maintaining a tight control of the supply of crude oil, and not least signs of tightness across key commodities that will help offset the risk of an economic slowdown across key economies.
Commodity articles:
19 Dec 2023: Crude and gas pop on Red Sea Disruption Risks
14 Dec 2023: Fed's dovish tilt adds fresh fuel to precious metals
13 Dec 2023: Video - Why gold may enjoy a Santa rally for the 7th year in a row
12 Dec 2023: Video - Investing in Uranium
1 Dec 2023: Commodity weekly: Tight supply risks boost copper; OPEC+ struggles to control crude
30 Nov 2023: Precious metals take top spot for a second month
23 Nov 2023: A nervous crude oil market awaits OPEC's next move
23 Nov 2023: Podcast: Will Santa deliver another golden gift
22 Nov 2023: Will gold and silver see another Santa rally?
17 Nov 2023: Commodity weekly: Crude overshoots; silver the comeback kid
16 Nov 2023: Podcast: Silver comeback, watch OPEC as crude oil slides lower
16 Nov 2023: Crude oil weakness adds focus to upcoming OPEC meeting
15 Nov 2023: Soft CPI lifts gold and beaten down silver and platinum
12 Nov 2023: Copper supported by green transformation demand and peak rate speculation
10 Nov 2023: Commodity weekly: Crude oil risks overshooting the downside
Previous "Commitment of Traders" articles
18 Dec 2023: COT: Crude long hits 12-year low ahead of FOMC bounce
11 Dec 2023: COT: An underowned commodity sector raising risk of an upside surprise in 2024
4 Dec 2023: COT: Speculators add further fuel to gold rally
20 Nov 2023: COT: Crude selling slows, grains in demand
14 Nov 2023: COT: Crude long slumps; agriculture sector in demand
Quarterly Outlook
Chief Investment Strategist
Quarterly Outlook
Head of Fixed Income Strategy
Quarterly Outlook
Chief Investment Strategist
Quarterly Outlook
Head of FX Strategy
Quarterly Outlook
Head of Commodity Strategy
Quarterly Outlook
Head of FX Strategy
Quarterly Outlook
Chief Investment Strategist
Quarterly Outlook
Chief Investment Strategist
Quarterly Outlook
Head of Fixed Income Strategy
Quarterly Outlook
Head of Commodity Strategy