Quarterly Outlook
Macro Outlook: The US rate cut cycle has begun
Peter Garnry
Chief Investment Strategist
Chief Investment Strategist
Summary: Nvidia shares are up 27% in pre-market trading as the company last night reported Q2 revenue outlook of USD 11bn vs est. USD 7.2bn smashing even the most optimistic estimates for revenue highlighting an incredible jump in demand for AI chips as the AI race is on following the commercial success of chatbots such as ChatGPT and Bard. The extremely high expectations for the future of Nvidia are clearly seen in its equity valuation which now owns the top spot in the S&P Index.
We can confidently say that we have never seen anything like Nvidia’s result last night from a company with a market value close to $1trn and high implied expectations based on the price action into the earnings release. Nvidia announced in late February in their investor presentation that they expected revenue of $6.5bn for the FY24 Q1 ending 30 April. Last night the company reported $7.2bn in revenue highlighting the quick and unanticipated shift in demand from the massive excitement and adoption of ChatGPT and later Google’s chatbot Bard.
One thing is missing revenue by more than 10% in just two months, but Nvidia’s Q2 revenue outlook was absurd guiding $11bn (light blue bar in the chart below) plus or minus 2% compared to expectations of $7.2bn. This will catapult Nvidia revenue into a new all-time high by the end of July. Analysts had clearly no clue about the underlying demand underscore that nobody has a good revenue model for Nvidia driven by a true understanding of the causal factors driving revenue. But investors were also not prepared for these figures as even their high expectations, reflected in the 109% rise in the share price, were crushed given that Nvidia shares are up 27% in pre-market trading.
Nvidia said that the underlying demand for their AI chips has just started with the CEO Jensen saying this was the beginning of a 10-year cycle. While these comments of course are genuine they also reflect a poor understanding of the potential bubble AI related stocks such as Nvidia is part of. A comment like this will just add to the bubble dynamics sucking many retail investors into the stock which is already reflecting huge expectations. The issue that nobody has any idea of where we are in 10 years from now. The outcome range for AI chips is extreme and because of this significant variance the pricing of Nvidia is almost impossible leading to a high probability of mispricing and even a bubble-like dynamics.
The enterprise value of Nvidia is up as much as the upward revision to the 12-month forward revenue meaning there is no change in the forward valuation of Nvidia post the earnings release. The 12-month forward EV/Sales ratio is still 22.3x compared to 1.1x around 10 years ago reflecting both the strong underlying growth dynamics and improved operating margins, but even more importantly investors’ extrapolation of AI technology into the future as something that is more or less unbounded. Nvidia has the highest 12-month forward EV/Sales of any stock in the S&P 500 Index.
The 12-month forward EV/Sales ratio is one of the best quant factors in backtesting with a significant Q-ratio, meaning that the return spread between the lowest and highest decile groups of stocks is quite significant. In other words, stocks with the highest EV/Sales ratio tend to significantly underperform stocks with the lowest EV/Sales ratio. These observations are naturally a phenomenon of aggregation and there will always be outliers. Amazon was one of those outliers for almost two decades. So maybe Nvidia is also one of these occasional outliers defying the aggregate observations. The important difference between Amazon and Nvidia is that Amazon defied the aggregate dynamic because it came from a small size swimming into a vast ocean of growth, while Nvidia is starting in a pole position on valuation with a market value already close to $1trn.
In Nvidia’s investor presentation from this February the chipmaker says that the market opportunity is around $1trn in revenue. Whether this figure is the total revenue in these categories or the revenue opportunity available for Nvidia with some x market share is not clear. But the slide helps shape a particular narrative about how big they see this market. For reference the global economy is expected to grow to $106trn in current USD prices this year.
However this market opportunity does not come without risks and it is our obligation as investment analysts to point out these risks. In our equity note Great opportunities and risks lie ahead for semiconductors we highlight two key risks, but we should add another one here, so the three key risks for Nvidia and the overall AI and semiconductor theme are these: